New England Oysters — Our Choice, Your Surprise

Not sure which oyster to try? Let us pick for you. This is one of our most popular options for oyster lovers who want to explore the best of what the East Coast has to offer without having to choose a specific variety. Our team hand-selects 25 premium oysters from the finest growing regions in New England and Atlantic Canada, chosen based on what is freshest and at peak quality on the day your order ships.

• Curated by Our Team: Every selection is made by people who know oysters. We choose based on freshness, quality, and what is at its best that week — not what needs to move.
• Premium Growing Regions: All oysters are sourced exclusively from Cape Cod, Prince Edward Island, or Maine — three of the most celebrated oyster-producing regions on the East Coast, known for their cold, clean waters and exceptional flavor profiles.
• Perfect for Exploration: Ideal for oyster enthusiasts who want to try something new, or for anyone hosting a raw bar and wanting a curated, high-quality selection without the guesswork.
• 25 Pieces: A generous quantity, perfect for a dinner party, a special occasion, or a personal indulgence.

How to Enjoy: Serve on the half shell over crushed ice with mignonette sauce, fresh lemon, and hot sauce. Or steam, grill, or bake for a warm preparation. Each oyster will have its own unique flavor profile — part of the fun is discovering what you receive.